Head to head
Breville Infuser vs Gaggia Classic Pro
Breville Infuser versus Gaggia Classic Pro: two manual espresso machines compared on temperature control, portafilter, boiler, and the modding community.
Quick verdict
Our recommendation
Buy the Breville Infuser if you own a grinder and want temperature control in a forgiving package: adjustable temperature, pre-infusion, and a 54 mm ecosystem that just works. Buy the Gaggia Classic Pro if you are a hobbyist who wants the commercial 58 mm group, the modding community, and a machine to keep for a decade. The Infuser is the learner's machine; the Gaggia is the tinkerer's machine.
Infuser BES840 vs Classic Pro RI9380: the spec sheet
| Product | Pump | Portafilter | Water tank | Extraction | Temperature | Valve |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Breville Infuser BES840 | 15-bar Italian pump | 54 mm | 61 oz | Low-pressure pre-infusion | Adjustable temperature control | - |
| Gaggia Classic Pro RI9380 | 15-bar ULKA, factory set to 9 bar (E24) | 58mm stainless steel | 72 oz (2.1 L) | - | - | 3-way solenoid |
Swipe sideways to compare all columns

The two contenders
Breville Infuser BES840
The Barista Express minus the grinder, with adjustable temperature control.
- Pump: 15-bar Italian pump
- Extraction: Low-pressure pre-infusion
Sources: Breville official product specifications, Major retailer product listings, Published coffee gear reviews
Check current priceGaggia Classic Pro RI9380
The modder's classic: commercial 58mm group, 3-way solenoid, and a huge owner community.
- Pump: 15-bar ULKA, factory set to 9 bar (E24)
- Portafilter: 58mm stainless steel
Sources: Gaggia official product specifications, Major retailer product listings, Published coffee gear reviews
Check current priceTemperature control
The Infuser is the only machine in this band with adjustable temperature control, which matters once you start buying lighter roasts that extract better hotter. The Gaggia has no PID and no adjustable temperature, so temperature surfing is part of ownership: the drinker learns to time shots around the boiler's cycle. That is a skill, not a feature, and it is the Gaggia's most honest demand. A buyer who wants to set a temperature and forget it should buy the Infuser; a buyer who enjoys the ritual of surfing should buy the Gaggia.
Portafilter and group
The Gaggia carries the commercial standard: a 58 mm stainless steel portafilter and commercial group head, the size every cafe uses, with the full accessory market behind it. The Infuser uses a 54 mm portafilter, the Breville standard, with a smaller but still healthy accessory market. The Gaggia's 3-way solenoid valve dries the puck and stops post-shot dripping, which the Infuser matches with low-pressure pre-infusion for even extraction. For a buyer who already owns 58 mm accessories, the Gaggia is the only choice; for a buyer starting fresh, both sizes work.
Boiler and waiting
Both machines make you wait between brewing and steaming, but differently: the Gaggia's single boiler means a real wait while it heats for steam, and the Infuser's thermocoil lags the ThermoJet Bambino models on heat-up. Neither is a dual boiler, so milk drinks are always a two-step routine. The Gaggia's 72 oz tank is the largest here against the Infuser's 61 oz, so the Gaggia refills less often. Neither machine is fast; the Infuser is the quicker of the two to temperature, and the Gaggia is the one with the bigger tank.
Steam wand
Both wands are manual and both reward practice, but they are different tools: the Gaggia has a commercial steam wand, not a panarello, for real microfoam, while the Infuser's manual microfoam wand gives real latte art practice in the Breville style. Neither textures milk at the press of a button. The Gaggia's wand is the more powerful of the two once the boiler is up to steam temperature, and the Infuser's is the more forgiving for a learner. Buyers who want automatic milk should look at the super-automatic rankings instead.
Modding and community
The Gaggia's greatest asset is not a spec but a community: a large modding community and ready parts supply stand behind the machine, with PID kits and shower screen upgrades that turn a mid-priced machine into a near-commercial one over time. The Infuser has no comparable modding scene, and its value is in what it does out of the box: temperature control, pre-infusion, and a forgiving workflow. Buy the Gaggia if the machine is a project; buy the Infuser if the machine is an appliance.
Which should you buy?
Choose the Breville Infuser BES840 if…
- You already own a grinder, and the Infuser's adjustable temperature control is the feature you will actually use.
- You want a forgiving manual machine that works well out of the box, with no mods needed.
- Lighter roasts are on the menu, and temperature control matters for extraction.
Choose the Gaggia Classic Pro RI9380 if…
- You are a hobbyist who wants the commercial 58 mm group and the modding community behind it.
- You want a machine to keep for a decade, with parts available and upgrades to grow into.
- The 72 oz tank and the commercial steam wand matter more than temperature control.
What to expect day to day
Breville Infuser BES840
Our notes on living with the Breville Infuser BES840, drawn from its documented strengths and limitations. These are editorial expectations, not owner reviews or survey results.
Where it makes life easier
- Adjustable temperature control helps dial in light versus dark roasts
- Low-pressure pre-infusion gives even extraction, as on the Express
- The manual microfoam steam wand gives real latte art practice
What to plan around
- With no grinder built in, it only makes sense if you already own one
- The thermocoil heat-up lags the ThermoJet Bambino models
- The older interface lacks the LCD shot timer the Pro offers
- Breville's US site no longer lists it, so buy from remaining Amazon stock and confirm the warranty
Gaggia Classic Pro RI9380
Our notes on living with the Gaggia Classic Pro RI9380, drawn from its documented strengths and limitations. These are editorial expectations, not owner reviews or survey results.
Where it makes life easier
- The 58mm stainless steel portafilter matches the commercial standard
- The 3-way solenoid leaves dry pucks and allows quick back-to-back shots
- A large modding community and ready parts supply stand behind the machine
- The current E24 version's brass boiler and factory 9-bar setting remove the two classic mods from the shopping list
What to plan around
- There is no automation; every step from grinding onward is manual
- The single boiler makes you wait between brewing and steaming
- Without a PID mod, temperature surfing becomes part of the routine for the best shots
Questions, answered
Do I need a grinder with the Infuser or the Gaggia?
Yes, a good one, for both: neither machine includes a grinder, and both need fresh, properly ground coffee to show what they can do. The Gaggia is the more demanding of the two, since its commercial group exposes a bad grind immediately, while the Infuser's pre-infusion forgives more. Budget a separate burr grinder on top of either machine, or buy the Barista Express, which includes one.
Which one is better for a beginner?
The Infuser: adjustable temperature control, low-pressure pre-infusion, and a forgiving workflow make it the easier machine to learn on, and it works well out of the box. The Gaggia rewards tinkering and punishes idleness; a beginner who does not want to temperature-surf or mod will find it frustrating. Learn on the Infuser, graduate to the Gaggia if the hobby takes hold.
Is the Gaggia Classic Pro worth modding?
Yes, if the hobby is the point: a PID kit removes the temperature surfing, and the 58 mm group takes every commercial accessory. The old pressure mod is no longer needed: the current E24 ships with a factory-fitted 9-bar OPV spring. The modding community is large and the parts supply is ready. If mods do not interest you, buy the Infuser instead, since its temperature control is built in and needs no kit.
Which machine steams milk better?
The Gaggia, once the boiler is up to steam temperature: its commercial wand is more powerful than the Infuser's manual wand. Both need technique, and neither is automatic. The Infuser is the more forgiving wand for a learner, while the Gaggia's rewards practice with better microfoam. Milk drinkers who want no technique at all should look at the super-automatic rankings.

